The Straits Times: New security law in HK under scrutiny


JAN 3, 2003

ASIA DEBRIEF

THE Hongkong government is now working on a draft of a security law, which has become the territory's most divisive and emotive issue since 1997 when Hongkong reverted to Chinese sovereignty.

Church leaders, academics, culture groups, bankers, lawyers, librarians, teachers, journalists, foreign businessmen, college students and others have spoken out against many of its vague provisions on treason, secession, subversion, sedition and theft of state secrets.

What also upset opponents, who are wary of Beijing, is that officials have admitted frankly that the government consulted China, and both sides agreed on the thrust of the legislation and that it would be enacted by July.

Furthermore, the administration ended a three-month consultation period on Dec 24 as it had started the exercise - by refusing to publish a white paper on the legislation to avoid any delay in passing it.

Although officials say a report on the 90,000 public submissions would be released this month, it is unlikely to appease opponents, who want to see technical and legal details.

The government's attitude has made the exercise appear consultative only in name, and resulted in a belief that while the administration might make token amendments to incorporate public views, the thrust of the legislation would remain unchanged.

These moves rekindled fears simmering since 1989, when Article 23, which requires Hongkong to enact anti-subversion laws, was written into the Basic Law. This happened just after the Tiananmen crackdown.

Some analysts believe the government has to pass the law this year as Beijing is nervous about instability in Hongkong in the next few years, seen as a sensitive political time for the territory.

For one thing, the Hongkong government would have to implement unpopular measures over the next several years, such as cutting civil servants' pays and welfare spending, as it aims to eliminate the ballooning budget deficit by 2006-2007.

For another, the Basic Law states that Hongkong may have full elections in 2007. But critics say this is unlikely to happen as Beijing has already ruled out such a possibility.

While little was said over the New Year about the controversial Bill, this is only the lull before the storm. In the months ahead, the government's actions are likely to come under increasing public scrutiny.

http://www.straitstimes.com.sg/storyprintfriendly/0,1887,164053,00.html?

 Yearly Archive   Printer Version


We welcome your comments and suggestions, please email:
feedback@clearwisdom.net


Related Articles

Article Review
President of National Taiwan University Wei-Jao Chen Praises Falun Dafa [1/6/2003]
MIT Falun Dafa Club, MIT Chapter of Amnesty International and MIT's Program on Human Rights and Justice Jointly Hold a Forum Entitled "Rescue Our Family Members" (Photo) [1/6/2003]
CCTV Slanders Falun Gong by Lying About the Real Reason Behind Cao Yuzhen's Suicide [1/6/2003]
More Falun Dafa Practitioners Around the World Wish Teacher a Happy New Year [1/5/2003]
A New Practitioner: "Falun Dafa Gave Me a Second Life" [1/5/2003]
Wang Xinzhong Is Arrested For Revealing the Truth About CCTV Propaganda Slandering His Son and Falun Dafa [1/5/2003]
A Chinese Government Employee Spreads the Truth after Chatting With a Western Falun Gong Practitioner on the Internet [1/4/2003]
At 50 Years Old, I Haven't Been Ill for Five Years [1/4/2003]
Third Party Commentary: Behind China's Increasing GDP [1/4/2003]
Urgent! Overseas Fellow Practitioners, Please Help Rescue Zhengzhou Falun Dafa Practitioner, Mr. Song Xu (Photos and Phone Numbers) [1/4/2003]
FDI: U.S. Woman, Harvard Graduate Seeks to Rescue Mother from Torture in China [1/4/2003]
We Hope That the US Government Will Firmly Resist Pressure from Jiang's Gang of Political Scoundrels [1/3/2003]
Washington Post: Defense Lawyers In China Find State Is Judge and Jury [1/3/2003]
Some Further Thoughts About the Lawsuit Against Jiang [1/3/2003]
A Police Officer Helps Falun Gong Practitioners After July 20, 1999 [1/2/2003]
Several Issues Surrounding the Lawsuit Against Jiang [1/2/2003]
FDI: International Campaign Rescues Twin Sister from Chinese Labour Camp (Photo) [1/1/2003]
Research Report in Taiwan Illustrates Power of Falun Gong to Improve Physical and Emotional Health while Reducing Health Care Expenses (Photos) [1/1/2003]
Speech Given by the Vice Interior Minister of Taiwan, Mr. Hsu Ying-Shen, at the 2002 Taiwan Falun Dafa Conference [1/1/2003]
Taiwan Vice President Lu Hsiu-Lien Sends Her Congratulations and Best Regards to the Taiwan Falun Dafa Experience Sharing Conference [1/1/2003]
More Articles...