World Organization to Investigate the Persecution of Falun Gong
January 10, 2004
Overview
Since the Jiang Zemin regime began persecuting Falun Gong in July 1999, the
Chinese media has launched a propaganda campaign to slander Falun Gong, incite
hatred, and deceive the Chinese people. Typically, the most influential
propaganda reports are first published or broadcast on top-level national media,
including China Central Television (CCTV), Xinhua News Agency, Chinese Daily,
Chinese News Agency, Guangming Daily, Liberation Army News, and
Chinese Youth News. The falsifications are then republished or rebroadcast
in all local media. The defamatory propaganda disseminated by the State-run
media is the cornerstone of the persecution. Deceptive propaganda, coupled with
coercion and incentives, enable the regime to engage all levels of society in
accepting or even directly participating in the persecution.
At the beginning of the persecution, Jiang's regime established the "610
Office" (an agency specifically created to persecute Falun Gong, with
absolute power over each level of administration in the Communist Party and all
other political and judiciary systems) and its propaganda machinery. Liu
Yunshan heads the 610 Office. Liu is also the committee member of the Central
Political Bureau, the secretary of the Central Secretary Office, and the
director of the Chinese Propaganda Department. Li Dongsheng, the deputy director
of the central 610 Office, is the deputy assistant in the team (1). As a crucial
member of the 610 Office, Li is also the deputy director of the Central Chinese
TV station and the secretary of the Party Committee. He bears responsibility for
CCTV's systematic lies to defame Falun Gong. The main goal of Li's propaganda
team is to direct the resources of the State media towards defaming Falun Gong
and promoting the systematic persecution.
The news media controlled by Jiang's regime serves as the Party's mouthpiece.
During the "Sixty Minutes" interview with Wallace on CBS, Jiang admitted, "Media
should be the Party's voice." This comment was later edited out of the Chinese
version of the interview that was aired by the Chinese government. Jiang also
said that the news media must follow "the will and interest of the Party and its
people and should serve as the guide of public opinion."
On January 2, 1996, in his address to high-ranking officials of the
Liberation Army News, Jiang said, "Our well-operated news media can be a
powerful tool in echoing and implementing our Party's policy, principles and
mission," and "All Party newspapers, journals, national news agencies,
broadcasting stations and TV stations must actively propagandize the Party's
position in order to play a major role in guiding public opinions." Jiang
further said, "All levels of the Party Committee should frequently discuss the
work of the news media. For example, the propaganda policy highlights and the
effect of propaganda, etc. must be discussed periodically in Party Committee
meetings. The comrade in charge needs to inquire about the news propaganda in
person." (2) Under the control of Jiang's regime, the Chinese news media have no
credibility. They merely serve as tools to deceive people and to carry out
Jiang's policy of eradicating Falun Gong.
On July 23,1999, a China Daily editorial article entitled "Enhance
Your Understanding and Realize the Danger; Hold on to the Policy and Maintain
Stability" falsely claimed that Falun Gong promotes doomsday theories about the
earth exploding, etc. The Xinhua News Agency broadcast the TV series "Spring
Breeze Will Bring You Back," with CCTV's news highlights: "Awaken -- A Story of
a Former Falun Gong Practitioner," and "Reborn from Hell -- A Documentary of
Wang Bo and Her Parents" in order to mislead the public about Falun Gong and the
government's harsh measures against practitioners. Falun Gong books, tapes and
audio-visual materials have been prohibited and destroyed. Therefore, the public
has no way to know the truth about Falun Gong. The news media has created a
rationale for Jiang's campaign to eradicate Falun Gong. As a result, Falun Gong
practitioners are illegally detained and have been tortured mentally and
physically in order to force them not only to give up their beliefs but also to
participate in attacking Falun Gong.
When the propaganda campaign seemed to be losing ground in deceiving people,
CCTV and Xinhua News Agency conspired in fabricating grave crimes to frame Falun
Gong, such as the staged self-immolation incident in Tiananmen Square, and two
alleged murder cases, "the bloody case in Beijing," and the "brutal murders of
beggars in Zhejiang province." The purpose was to incite hatred against Falun
Gong practitioners to justify an escalation of the persecution.
Many Chinese media agencies have aided Jiang in his campaign against Falun
Gong. Many of the journalists in the State-run media agencies appear to have
completely lost their professional ethics when they violate the fundamental
principle of truth in journalism. As a tool of persecution, the Chinese news
media can be compared to the Nazi Propaganda Department in World War II. The
media's lies have either directly or indirectly led to the deaths of hundreds of
Falun Gong practitioners. Untold numbers, tens or even hundreds of thousands of
practitioners, have been detained or forced to flee from their homes. Millions
of practitioners and their families have suffered all kinds of losses--loss of
freedom of travel, employment, pensions, housing, education, and basic human
rights.
Because of the severity of the harm caused by Jiang's propaganda's machine,
WOIPFG has carried out a series of investigations on the individuals and work
units that have been involved in fabricating lies and inciting hatred.
--
1. Propaganda Lays the Groundwork for the Persecution
The fabrication of news and the manipulation of public opinion by China's
State-controlled media have enabled the persecution to continue and even
escalate.
On June 7, 1999, Jiang gave a talk at the Central Politburo meeting about the
need to solve the Falun Gong issue. On July 24, the Press and Publication
Administration issued the "Notice on Immediate Confiscation and Concealment of
Five Books, Including China Falun Gong." This notice banned the four
books--Explaining the Principles of Zhuan Falun, Falun Dafa (Lecture
in Sydney), Falun Dafa (Lecture in Europe Fa Conference) and Falun
Dafa (Lecture at the First Conference in North America), which had been
approved by the Press and Publication Administration for publication by Qinhai
People's Publishing House of Qinghai Province Press and by the Publication
Department only a few days earlier on June 1, 1999.
On July 22, 1999, the Ministry of Civil Affairs announced the decision to ban
the Falun Dafa Research Association. The Ministry of Public Security announced
that, "According to 'Regulations Regarding Management of Audio and Visual
Products,' any audio/visual products promoting Falun Dafa (Falun Gong), ... must
be banned. Also, all levels of cultural administrative departments and
audio/visual product management departments must immediately search the
audio/visual product market and prohibit any groups or individuals from
wholesaling, selling, renting or showing any audio/visual products that promote
Falun Dafa. Once identified, these products must be confiscated and destroyed
immediately, and those found possessing these items must be punished
accordingly." On July 28, 1999, CCTV (China Central Television) reported that,
"... In the past several days [the government] confiscated Falun Gong books and
audio/visual materials, and destroyed them in large quantities. Sources said
that the press management department in Tianjin confiscated twenty-two types of
Falun Gong books that totaled over 73,000 copies. The Public Security Department
in Wuhan destroyed en masse about 130,000 Falun Gong publications, which
included 100,000 books and 27,000 audio/visual materials."
Since then, the public has been unable to access authentic Falun Gong
material, and thus they are deprived of the right to know the truth about Falun
Gong. The central propaganda agencies and media started to defame Falun Gong by
quoting out of context from the books and spreading lies.
1.1 Quoting out of Context and Sheer Fabrication
On July 23, 1999, a People's Daily (Chinese Communist Party's official
newspaper) editorial entitled "Improve Your Understanding, Discern Harmfulness,
Implement Policies, and Protect Stability," claimed that Falun Gong "preaches
that the Earth will explode and doomsday is coming." However, Mr. Li Hongzhi,
the founder of Falun Gong stated in his 1998 lecture in the U.S., "I can
proclaim here to everyone in all earnestness that all of those alleged
catastrophes on earth, the doom of the universe, and things of this sort in the
year 1999 are absolutely nonexistent." (3)
CCTV broadcast a press conference for foreign reporters hosted by the State
Council's Bureau of Religious Affairs and played a video recording alleged to be
a lecture by Mr. Li Hongzhi. CCTV had edited the tape by cutting out the "non"
from "and things of this sort in the year 1999 are absolutely nonexistent."
Editors then recombined the sentence with some other sentences that were also
out of the context. In this way, they turned the lecture into "preaching about
the explosion of the Earth," thus changing Mr. Li Hongzhi's lecture to make it
appear to state the opposite of the original. The "doomsday allegation" is also
a distortion of a reference in Falun Gong books to our present time as the
"Dharma-ending period," a term first used by Sakymuni. Many other fabrications
found in China's propaganda similarly take words out of context and reconstruct
recorded statements.
1.2 Using Rumors and False Witnesses
On July 28, 1999, a reporter from Xinhua agency started a rumor to discredit
Mr. Li Hongzhi by publishing an article called "Pan Yufang Testifies That Li
Hongzhi Lied about His Birthday." This article claimed that, "eighty-year-old
Pan Yufang still has a very fresh memory. According to Pan Yufang, in the summer
of 1952, when she was thirty-three years old, she was invited to Gongzhuling,
Huaide County, Jilin Province to deliver a baby for Lu Shuzhen. Because of labor
complications, Lu Shuzhen was in a lot of pain, so Pan Yufang had to inject
Oxytocin (pitocin) to induce the birth. When the baby came out, his whole body
was purple. This baby was Li Hongzhi." However, according to Columbia
Encyclopedia (Columbia University, the 5th edition, 1993), the
molecular structure of Oxytocin was found in 1953, and it was also in 1953 that
scientists first synthesized it in the laboratory. Its use in hospitals did not
occur until after 1953.
1.3 Falsely Attributing Crimes to Falun Gong
The Chinese media exploits crimes to make false accusations against Falun
Gong. For example, on December 29, 1999, the CCTV nightly news and the program
"Focal Point Interview" reported on the "Zou Gang murder case." Zou Gang,
thirty-nine years old, was an employee in the Seed Station of Songhuajing City
Forest Management Branch of the Forest Industrial Bureau in Heilongjiang
province. Since he was a child, Zou Gang had suffered some abnormal mental
symptoms such as hearing noises, hallucinating and experiencing paranoia. The
day before he committed a murder, his relatives had called the Harbin Mental
Hospital to discuss his unstable situation with the doctors (5). According to a
prison inmate jailed with Zou Gang, the CCTV "Focal Point Interview" reporters
promised Zou Gang that he would not be sentenced to death if he cooperated with
them by saying that he committed murder as a result of practicing Falun Gong.
After he complied and made the false claim, however, he was still sentenced to
death, undoubtedly to keep the arrangement secret. "The Report on the Criminal
Case of 'Self-called' Falun Gong Practitioner -- Zou Gang," published in The
Inner Reference in Heilongjiang Province, Issue II, Jan. 22, 2000, pointed
out that reporters had investigated Zou Gang's case with the Police Department
and other relevant departments, and had found that there was no evidence that he
was a Falun Gong practitioner except his own claim. According to the main book
of Falun Gong, Zhuan Falun (Chapter 7, section 1), Falun Gong's teachings
prohibit killing: "The issue of killing is very sensitive. For practitioners, we
have set the strict requirement that they cannot kill lives." However, in spite
of the fact that Falun Gong teachings are explicitly against killing, the
government used the media to attack Falun Gong by circulating rumors that Falun
Gong practitioners had committed some widely publicized murders as well as self
inflicted injuries. The purpose was to incite hatred against Falun Gong.
2. Covering up the Persecution
The Jiang regime's suppression of Falun Gong, initiated in July 1999,
violates the constitution as well as the International Human Rights Treaty.
Since that time, more than 100,000 Falun Gong practitioners have been illegally
detained in hundreds of forced labor camps in China. (8) Jiang issued secret
orders to "defame their reputations, bankrupt them financially, and destroy them
physically." The detention centers, forced labor camps and prisons in China have
adopted brutal methods to persecute Falun Gong practitioners in order to force
them renounce their beliefs and even participate in the persecution. The methods
of torture include: extended sleep deprivation, extensive use of multiple high
voltage electric batons, the dungeon, the water dungeon, the "dead person's
bed," sitting planks, painful and life-threatening force-feedings, and "strait
jackets." To date, at least 869 Falun Gong practitioners are known to have been
tortured to death (9). However, the state media in China not only cover up the
brutality of the persecution, they are also paint a false picture of labor camps
and detention centers.
2.1 CCTV, China's State-run TV Station, Fabricates News
Professor Zhang Kunlun, a renowned sculptor currently residing
in Canada, was seized three times for practicing Falun Gong when he lived in
Shandong Province, China. Professor Zhang reported, "Several policemen pressed
me onto the ground all of a sudden and kicked and hit me violently. Before
torturing me, the head of the police station claimed, 'The highest leader,
President Jiang, declared, 'It does not matter how badly you torture Falun Gong
practitioners. If they die, just bury them and say they committed suicide for
dread of punishment for their crimes.' Then they shocked me with electric batons
all over my body and two policemen shocked me at the same time... It was so
painful, and I was not allowed to shout. They would jab the electric baton into
my mouth if I shouted..."
Professor Zhang was rescued as a result of the efforts of private citizens
and the Canadian government. He returned to Canada and exposed the fabrications
of a CCTV program, which had broadcast a video-clip of professor Zhang painting
and watching others playing Chinese chess. The footage painted a rosy picture of
prison life in China. Professor Zhang described how the scene was fabricated: "
In reality they are making a show! At that time, a commissar said that a person
who teaches painting hoped that I could provide him some guidance. They put out
papers, pen and ink and insisted on my instruction. I did not know it was a trap
and said to them, 'Let me draw a bit and let you see.' They video recorded the
moment when I was drawing. I only realized this after seeing the TV program.
Regarding the scenes they broadcast of prisoners playing chess, these types of
fabrications are what make it hard for people to know the severity of China's
labor camp system. On the day they recorded the video, they brought chess and
poker and let everyone play together. They asked me to play, but I replied that
I did not know how to play poker and did not understand chess either. They said
to me: 'Just sit here and take a look if you do not know how to play.' As they
were talking, they pressed me onto to the chair with force, and video recorded
the moment when I sat down. All of the scenes on TV are just a scam!" (10)
The same thing also happened to Zhao Ming, who had been studying in Ireland.
Zhao Ming was detained in 2000 when he went back to China to appeal. He suffered
many kinds of torture in Beijing's Tuanhe Forced Labor Camp. He reported, "In
the forced labor camp, everyday is a fierce battle. The police instigated many
criminals to beat me together. I was abused physically, not allowed to sleep and
shocked by a group of policemen surrounding me and using electric batons. They
first threatened me and asked me to 'transform.' After I firmly refused, they
began to tie me onto a bed board (to prevent my body from moving during the
electric shocking). They tied my feet, legs, upper body, and arms respectively,
with a cord through my mouth to tie my head. After they tied me onto the bed
board, they again threatened me and asked me to 'transform.' After I refused
again, they brought a bundle of electric batons and began to distribute them.
The electric batons are over fifty centimeters long. Other than the two
electrodes on the top, the whole electric baton is covered with spiral metal, if
this part is used, the electric shock can cover a long range. They used at least
six electric batons to shock all over my body." (11)
In the second half of 2001, CCTV reporter Li Yuqiang, who has made several TV
programs slandering Falun Gong, went to Tuanhe Forced Labor Camp where he
interviewed Zhao Ming for a whole afternoon. Zhao Ming described the experience,
"They appear to highly support Falun Gong and asked me when I began to
cultivate, what experiences and benefits I have from practicing Falun Gong.
Then, I told all my experiences about how I benefited both physically and
mentally during the cultivation of Falun Dafa and my understanding of Dafa
principles from the perspective of science. Ostensibly, it looked like a
pleasant interview that could only possibly happen before 1999." (11)
Zhao Ming was rescued by the efforts of the Irish government and private
citizens. When he returned to Ireland and saw the shots of this interview in an
anti-Falun Gong VCD produced by CCTV, he commented, "I found that it was the
shots of this interview, but they had manipulated the context of my words and
added voiceover. It was totally opposite of what I said, and they used this to
attack Falun Gong. In fact, they spent so much effort putting on an act to steal
some words from me and try to obliterate the fact that I had been tortured."
In a report entitled "There is Nothing the Spring Breeze Can Not Bring Back,"
Xinhua News Agency reporters Li Shanyuan, Yu Li, and Zhang Feifei characterized
the cruel tortures of Falun Gong practitioners as the "meticulous care of
policemen." They depicted the Masanjia Forced Labor Camp, which is notoriously
cruel in its abuse of Falun Gong practitioners, as the "cradle of educational
transformation, teacher of rebuilding the soul." These media spokesmen
misrepresented the brainwashing of Falun Gong practitioners as "transformation"
and "rescue," thus seriously distorting the facts and misleading the public.
(12) Because the State-run media made such fabrications and hid the truth, most
Chinese people do not know that Falun Gong practitioners are cruelly persecuted
and that many have even lost their lives for not giving up their beliefs.
2.2 The Persecution Breaks up Families -- The Story of Wang Bo's Family
On April 7 and 8, 2002, CCTV's "Focus Topic" program entitled "From
Destruction to Rebirth --Wang Bo and her Father and Mother" (13) and Xinhua News
Agency's report entitled "Life --Music--Rebirth --Former Falun Gong Practitioner
Wang Bo's Life Story" (14) distorted the facts to blame Falun Gong for the
breakup of the family when the breakup was actually caused by the persecution.
Wang Bo's parents were separated from the rest of the family when they were
illegally detained in a forced labor camp.
Wang Bo described how she was brainwashed: "It was extremely painful in the
forced labor camp. There was no personal freedom at all.... They detained me in
the Beijing Xin'an Forced Labor Camp. They did not allow me to sleep at all for
twenty-four hours a day for six continuous days. They indoctrinated me with lies
that reverse right and wrong, and forced me to watch tapes that distort Falun
Gong. They forcibly brainwashed me."
In the words of the policemen there, "We just use the kind of means that we
use to deal with spies to make you collapse mentally." (15) Wang Bo was forcibly
"transformed" when she was tortured to the point of mental collapse. They forced
Wang Bo to give up Falun Gong. She told her father, "Father, do you know how I
live these days? After being transformed, my mind is full of conflicts. I am
mentally depressed and feel life is bitterer than death. Sometimes I feel I am
like a person who is over sixty years old. I have already died mentally several
times...."
Wang Bo's father Wang Zhongxin described how he was also forcibly
"transformed": "I wasn't allowed to sleep for days. Under the deceit of all
kinds of lies that quote out of context and perpetrate fraud and tapes that
slander Falun Gong, and also the mental torture of not allowing me sleep for
many days, I became muddled and mentally disturbed and was so-called
'transformed.' But this was absolutely against my will." (15)
Wang Xinzhong described how the CCTV "Focus Topic" program fabricated its
story: "When I saw the program broadcast by "Focus Topic," I was shocked by such
contemptible blame of Falun Gong, distortion, slander and fabrication. During my
talk with the CCTV reporter, I talked about our family's cultivation and how
people from the 610 Office had beaten me in my workplace," but these were
deleted. They deceitfully substituted one thing for another, made important
deletions to change my talk, purposefully giving the program content that has a
totally different direction in order to defame cultivators and viciously attack
Dafa. A reporter said, 'Some content cannot be reported. It is the need of
politics.'" (15)
What is the true story of the Wang family's experience with Falun Gong that
CCTV misrepresented in its program? According to Wang Xinzhong, "Before 1996, my
wife and I did not have a good relationship, and we planned to get divorced
based on agreement after Wang Bo went to high school in 1996. Our family had a
crisis. In 1995, Wang Bo stopped learning piano, and my health was not good. I
had neurasthenia, myocarditis, gastroenteritis, and my wife had neurasthenia and
rotator cuff tendonitis. We often argued over very little things, would not
yield to the other person, and our conflicts became extreme. I was prepared to
get divorced. In July 1996, my wife began to cultivate Falun Gong, and I found
she changed greatly mentally and physically. Even her personality changed from
the cultivation, so I changed my view and attitude, and later I began to
cultivate too. We did things according to truthfulness, compassion, and
tolerance, always thought of other people and checked for our own faults
whenever there was a conflict. My wife and I communicated with each other,
understood each other. Our life once again thrived, and our family became
harmonious. All the illnesses disappeared. We threw away the big case that had
been used to store medicines for many years and returned to the house that was
used to prepare for the divorce. Wang Bo had a happy family." (15)
The story of Wang Bo's "transformation" is only one of many such stories
fabricated for propaganda. The media sided with the persecution to shift blame
for broken families from the government to Falun Gong practitioners themselves.
The media alleged that Falun Gong practitioners "do not care about families,"
"destroy their families," "have no human nature," etc. They never mentioned that
Falun Gong practitioners have benefited physically and mentally from cultivating
Falun Gong. The media characterized Falun Gong practitioners' perseverance in
reporting the truth as "being stubborn." They reversed right and wrong, good and
evil, by presenting the persecution as an effort to save lives. What does it
mean to "transform" a person through brainwashing? Kong Fanyun, from the
Educational Center of the Legal System told the people who had been transformed,
"The time when I see you beat people and curse people is when you are truly and
completely transformed." (15)
3. The "Tiananmen Square Self-Immolation" Story -- A
Fabrication
Chinese media claimed that, on the afternoon of January 23,
2001, a "self-immolation" took place on Tiananmen Square, Beijing. The Chinese
Government's mouthpiece, Xinhua News Agency and CCTV, immediately reported the
incident, claiming the five individuals who set themselves on fire were Falun
Gong practitioners.?Their quick response was in stark contrast to the way
news is usually handled in China, with lower-level officials reporting to
superiors until top officials allow the report to be published.?
An act of "self-immolation" would be a serious violation of
Falun Gong's principles and teachings, which explicitly state, "For
practitioners, we have set the strict requirement that they cannot kill
lives."(7) "Therefore, committing suicide is sinful."(16) For this and other
reasons, Falun Gong practitioners rejected the charge that practitioners could
have participated in the act. Some third party agencies and international media
also raised questions regarding Beijing's allegations. Washington Post
journalist Philip Pan published an article after he interviewed the neighbors of
Liu Chunling, one of the alleged participants who lost her life in the
"self-immolation." Pan wrote, "None ever saw her practice Falun Gong." (17)
Reports from Focus Interview on CCTV were even more
questionable. Analysis of the "self-immolation" footage broadcast by CCTV showed
Liu Chunling was struck by a heavy object immediately before she was knocked to
the ground, indicating that she did not die from the fire but was murdered in
order to avoid any possible leaks. Her daughter Liu Siying, another alleged
participant, died suddenly on March 17 after appearing very lively and being
deemed ready to be discharged from the hospital. We can infer that, like her
mother, Liu Siying was murdered to prevent her from leaking the truth about the
staged event. (18)
Pictures: 1. (Left) Liu Chunling is facing the extinguisher. The fire on her body has
already been put out. At this very moment, an outstretched arm reaching toward
Liu Chunling's head is faintly visible. Liu is struck on the head.
2. (Middle) A heavy object hits Liu Chunling's head and
bounces up. Liu is struck so hard that she turns away from the extinguisher as
she is knocked to the ground.
3. (Right) Although Wang Jindong appears to have been
blackened or burned by the fire, the sprite bottle that was alleged to hold
gasoline remains intact between his legs. An officer standing behind Wang
Jindong holds a fire blanket but doesn't immediately apply it.
The National Taiwan University Language Laboratory conducted
an independent voice analysis of Wang Jindong, whose voice was broadcast in the
initial coverage of the "self-immolation" and again in the Focus Interview
program on CCTV one year later. Based on voice analysis, the researchers
concluded definitively that the "Wang Jindong" who first appeared on the scene
of the "self-immolation" was not the same person as the "Wang Jindong" who made
his appearance in the Focus Interview one year later. (19)
Li Yuqiang is a senior reporter for CCTV's Focus Interview
program. In early 2002, Li Yuqiang visited the brainwashing center known as the
"Law Education and Training Center for the Capital of Hebei Province" to
interview Wang Bo. During her visit, she talked with Falun Gong practitioners
illegally detained there. They brought out the suspicious nature of the CCTV
program containing the "self-immolation" scene. Practitioners pointed out the
incongruities to her, such as the fact that Wang Jindong seemed to have been
severely burned, yet the Sprite bottle of gasoline between his legs appeared to
have been untouched by the fire. Confronted with such evidence and their
analysis, Li Yuqiang acknowledged that officials had put the Sprite bottle
between Wang Jindong's legs after he had been burned and that the scene had been
staged. She admitted that the scene had been arranged in an attempt to convince
the public that Falun Gong practitioners had committed the "self-immolation."
She even admitted that if they had known that people would doubt its
authenticity, they would not have filmed the scene. (20)
The International Education Development (IED) office in USA California made
an official statement at the United Nations on August 14, 2001: "...The regime
points to a supposed self-immolation incident in Tiananmen Square on January 23,
2001 as proof to slander Falun Gong. However, we have obtained a video of that
incident that in our view proves that this event was staged by the government."
The alleged "Tiananmen Square Self-Immolation" was the first case that WOIPFG
investigated. Please refer to detailed reports from WOIPFG for more information.
(18) New Tang Dynasty TV, a non-profit privately owned Chinese language TV
station, produced a documentary film entitled "False Fire: China's Tragic New
Standard in State Deception." The film won a Certificate of Honorable Mention at
the 51st Columbus International Film and Video Festival. The movie
"False Fire" systematically analyzed many suspicious details of the
"self-immolation" incident. The analysis exposed beyond a doubt that the
self-immolation was staged and left the viewer to conclude that the event had
been directed by the Chinese government to frame Falun Gong and create a
rationale for the persecution.
The "self-immolation" incident occurred a little over one and a half years
after the suppression of Falun Gong was launched in July 1999. At the time of
the "self-immolation," the Chinese public had started to express disapproval of
Jiang's suppression of Falun Gong practitioners, and the campaign to turn public
opinion against Falun Gong appeared to be destined for failure. The staged
"self-immolation" incident instigated hatred toward Falun Gong practitioners and
turned the general public from Falun Gong sympathizers into people who accepted
the repression with indifference. Cases of hatred against Falun Gong increased
markedly after the widely publicized "self-immolation." Jiang's regime seized
the opportunity to intensify the persecution of Falun Gong practitioners.
According to incomplete statistics, during the first eighteen months of the
persecution, officially starting on July 20, 1999 (before the staged
"self-immolation" incident), 173 practitioners were persecuted to death. After
the "self-immolation" incident, the death toll increased sharply to 869 in the
following thirty-six months. (Among these victims, 696 practitioners died from
torture after the "self-immolation" incident.)
WOIPFG has conducted a number of investigations of the media and individuals
involved in this fabrication. Because all the reports on the "self-immolation"
from Xinhua News Agency were unsigned, WOIPFG has investigated the related
departments in Xinhua News Agency. The head of Xinhua News Agency Net center,
Zhou Xisheng claimed that he himself "was not in charge of this issue." WOIPFG
learned from other sources that the Department of Internal Affairs in Xinhua
News Agency was responsible for the "self-immolation" reports. The head of the
Department of Internal Affairs replied, "I can't help you look for the name of
the reporter of concern ...... Xinhua News Agency is not in a position to answer
questions related to Falun Gong." Several Focus Interview staff denied
their involvement in the production of the "self-immolation" video program. They
said they didn't know why their names showed up as video editors, etc. Some CCTV
staff members wouldn't admit who they were and denied their phone numbers were
CCTV numbers. Yang Taozhou, who was responsible for technical production,
admitted that he was engaged in the later-stage production of the
"self-immolation" videotape. Several stage staff of Focus Interview told
the investigator it was Li Yuqiang who was responsible for the production of all
Falun Gong related videotapes from the Focus Interview team. WOIPFG has
interviewed Li Yuqiang several times. When the investigator pointed out the
suspicious points in CCTV's "self-immolation" video, Li Yuqiang showed fear. She
said, " I don't understand what you are talking about. You have to talk to the
CCTV General Station first."
4. Using Mental Patients to Accuse Falun Gong of Murder
4.1 The Fu Yibin Murder Case
On December 16, 2001, Xinhua News Agency and two programs of CCTV--News
Report and Focus Interview--launched another round of attacks against
Falun Gong with a defamatory report entitled "Capital Murder--Fu Yibin Kills His
Father and His Wife." This fabricated report escalated the slander and
defamation of Falun Gong from alleged suicide to murder. The level of
fabrication also intensified from quoting out of the context and reconstructing
text to "pure fiction." In Focus Interview, Fu Yibing said, "I killed all
of them. When I succeed in my cultivation, my whole family will go to Paradise
and live a happy life forever." Such distorted logic--"killing is saving"--can't
be found in any Falun Gong books. On the contrary, Falun Gong's main publication
Zhuan Falun, states explicitly, "For practitioners, we have set
the strict requirement that they cannot kill lives." (7)
As Dr. Vivian Galli, an American psychiatrist, points
out, "From a psychiatric point of view, it is very clear that this is a
psychiatric case. Assuming that the perpetrator, Fu Yibin, is telling the truth
to the reporter, we can conclude that he was psychotic in November 2001 when he
killed his father and wife. Sadly, he still seemed to be psychotic during the
interview that took place on December 17, 2001. He was not only delusional but
he also was having command hallucinations and excessive energy at the time of
the killing. He also seemed to have a chronic psychiatric condition." (21)
In the Focus Interview on CCTV, mental patient Fu
Yibin appeared to speak with ease, not as one would expect of a prisoner
detained for murder.
Ms. Ma Ruijin, who knew one of Fu Yibin's relatives,
confirmed that Fu Yibin had a long history of mental disease. Ms. Ma stated,
"Actually, Fu Yibin has been insane for several years. One of his relatives
lived in the vicinity of Huangsi Street. That relative of his was my colleague.
It was around 1993 that his relative told us he often went around without any
clothes. His family members were unable to control him, no matter how hard they
tried. That is to say, as early as eight years ago, he was already insane." (22)
On December 16, 2001, a Canada-based Chinese TV station,
Television broadcast a report of the alleged Fu Yibin murder case made by CCTV.
On August 16, 2002, the Canadian Broadcast Standard Council announced a ruling
that the report by Television violated the Code of Ethics on news reports as
listed in the Canadian Broadcast and TV Regulations and other regulations
regarding violent content. Therefore, the report was deemed to be "improper and
unjust." (23)
4.2 Alleged Murder by Poisoning Case in Zhejiang Province
An article published on Xinhua Net on July 2, 2003 claimed that the
extraordinary June 26 poisoning case had been solved the night before, which
would be July 1, and that a Falun Gong practitioner had committed the murder.
When WOIPFG inquired on July 3, a member of the Department of Propaganda in
Cangnan County, Wenzhou City told the investigators that the case had not been
solved. He had not heard that the suspect was a Falun Gong practitioner, and
said that more than five hundred policemen were still assigned to investigate
this case. [24] On July 14, CCTV's Focal Point Interview reported that
seventeen beggars had been poisoned and claimed that the suspect was a Falun
Gong follower.
Chen Fuzhao, who was involved in the murder, was a diagnosed psychotic. Chen
Fuzhao's father, a medical center in Cangnan County, as well as the local
government of Longgang Town, in Cangnan County have all verified this fact. A
doctor who knows Chen Fuzhao told a WOIPFG investigator, "Chen Fuzhao has
been psychotic for many years." Before the poisoning-murder took place, Chen's
father took him to the Neian Mental Hospital for treatment. [25]
However, the Xinhua News Agency and CCTV reports intentionally omitted his
history of mental illness and instead attributed Chen Fuzhao's eccentric
behavior to Falun Gong. The Xinhua News Agency report of July 14 in particular
alleged that Chen Fuzhao committed murder due to his "reversed cultivation" of
the Falun Gong principles of Truth-Compassion-Tolerance. However, they did not
explain how behavior completely against Truth-Compassion-Tolerance could somehow
be connected with Falun Gong. Investigations reveal that the 610 Office was
behind the coverage of this murder case. The news reporter who is specially
engaged in slandering Falun Gong deliberately ignored Chen Fuzhao's psychotic
condition and claimed that his illogical statements were induced by his Falun
Gong practice; however, he failed to explain any connection. The report
insinuated further that Chen Fuzhao had committed a series of "beggar-murders"
out of need because he practiced Falun Gong. Such allegations furthered the
government's campaign to slander and persecute Falun Gong. The investigation
also discovered that people who knew about the deception were warned to keep
silent.
When an investigator from WOIPFG questioned the Zhejiang Branch of Xinhua
News Agency about the coverage, the reply was, "We are a government-run news
agency, and all of our published articles follow a specific line of rules and
regulations." We conduct interviews according to information provided by the
government. How we wrote the report and the process of writing it was not up to
any individual or the branch. It had to follow the requirements of the
department concerned, and it was written with group efforts from many people."
According to factual evidence collected by WOIPFG, it was found that:
1) The Xinhua News Agency and CCTV selected certain media to monopolize news
reports. All other media were excluded. 2) The selected media fabricated news
reports, including the fact that the undersigned reporter did not even
participate in gathering the news. In addition, many alleged witnesses who were
quoted in the news reports claimed that they had never been interviewed. 3) The
police and the central 610 Office were directly behind this case. Reporters from
Xinhua News Agency and people working in the special group selected who would
participate in investigating and reporting this case. Recently the reporters
have either been promoted or transferred elsewhere. [26]
Similar to the Beijing murder case, another case of a psychotic patient
committing murder was also used to frame Falun Gong practitioners. On December
30, 2003, Wenzhou Court, in Zhejiang Province, sentenced Chen Fuzhao to death.
This is not only against the law of China and relevant laws of the international
community, but is also appears to be an effort to do away with a witness. From
the murder of family members in the earlier Fu Yibin case to the group murder of
the Chen Fuzhao case, the evidence points to the fact that the Jiang Zemin group
has escalated the severity of its libel of Falun Gong. Such propaganda has
incited the Chinese public's hatred and fear of Falun Gong practitioners. People
have been deceived to the extent that they report on and aid in the arrest of
Falun Gong practitioners who try to clarify the truth. Thus the public has been
duped into cooperating with the persecution.
5. Falun Gong Practitioners Who Expose Media Lies Receive Harsh Sentences or
Death
The constitution of China and various international pacts that the Chinese
government has agreed to all state that people have freedom of speech and
freedom of belief. However, in the past four years, Falun Gong practitioners
have been completely deprived of these rights. Jiang's group has violated the
constitution of China and international agreements. The regime has directed all
TV stations and other propaganda machinery to slander and frame Falun Gong. In
order to allow people to learn the truth about Falun Gong and to expose the
persecution, Falun Gong practitioners have resorted to various peaceful means,
including tapping into cable TV systems.
On March 5, 2002, several Falun Gong practitioners in Changchun tapped into
the cable TV network to broadcast truth clarification videos about Falun Gong,
including "Falun Dafa Around the World" and "Self-immolation or Staged Act?"
This was considered the first large-scale civil act to break through the
one-sided state media propaganda since the Communist Party took power in 1949.
Because Jiang's group is terrified of people learning the truth, they sentenced
Falun Gong practitioners thought to be involved in the action to heavy prison
terms or had them tortured to death. On September 20, 2002, Changchun
Intermediate People's Court sentenced fifteen Falun Gong practitioners,
including Zhou Runjun, Liu Weiming, Liang Zhenxing, and Liu Chengjun to four to
twenty years' imprisonment. During the illegal trial, the judge and court
officials showed no concern for the policemen's vicious beating of Falun Gong
practitioners. [27]
On March 12, 2002, Liu Haibo died at the hands of the police from Kuancheng
Police Station. They had tried to extort a confession from him by torture
because he was suspected of providing room and board for Falun Gong
practitioners involved in the TV tapping incident. On March 18, 2002, police
beat Liu Yi to death in their office at Luyuan Police Station. On March 16,
2002, an unknown Falun Gong practitioner was beaten to death at Jincheng
substation under the jurisdiction of the Changchun City Police Department. [27]
Liu Chengjun, a Falun Gong practitioner from Nongan County, Jilin Province,
was one of the main participants in the cable TV tapping incident. After
twenty-one months of imprisonment and torture, Liu Chengjun died at 4:00 a.m. on
December 26, 2003. Witnesses saw blood running out of Liu Chengjun's nostrils,
ears, and thighs. At 11:00 a.m. that same day, Jilin Prison gathered many police
officers to forcibly cremate Liu Chengjun's body without conducting an autopsy,
despite protest from Liu Chengjun's family. During his detention, Liu Chengjun
was tortured with various means, including fifty-two days on the Tiger Bench.
[27]
6. Individuals and Work Units Involved in Media Fabrication
A small number of people working in the Chinese media didn't truthfully
report on the unjust persecution imposed on millions of Chinese citizens.
Instead, they made up lies to slander Falun Gong, which deceived the country's
media and the people into supporting the persecution. They thereby legitimized
the genocide, and became accomplices to the persecution. The following are the
main work units and individuals that took part in the media persecution of Falun
Gong.
Within the 610 Office, the person in charge of controlling the media is Liu
Yunshan, member of the Political Bureau of the CPC Central Committee, Party
Secretary of the Secretariat of the CPC Central Committee, Minister of the
Ministry of Propaganda, and core member of the 610 Office, the one who is mainly
in charge of the propaganda machinery for the persecution.
CCTV
The head of CCTV is Zhao Huayong. The deputy head is Li Dongsheng.
Since Jiang's group began the persecution of Falun Gong on July 20, 1999,
CCTV willingly cooperated with the persecution and made numerous TV programs
that slandered Falun Gong. Within less than two years, from April 25, 2002 to
the end of 2003, as many as 332 Falun Gong-slandering programs aired on the
Focal Point Interview, News Program, Science Channel, Parlance Weekly, China
Diplomacy Forum, TV Criticism, China Net Media Forum, Life Channel and other
TV channels.
The Focal Point Interview group of CCTV
The Focal Point Interview group has broadcast a series of cases that
viciously slandered Falun Gong, including "Tiananmen Self-immolation," "Murder
Case in Beijing," "Zhejiang Beggar Poisoning-murder" and has played an extremely
negative role in inciting hatred (see attachment 1). On August 21, 2003, Ji
Bingxuan, deputy head of the Propaganda Ministry stated in Focal Point
Interview, series 1, "On important propaganda issues such as exposing
and criticizing Falun Gong, Focal Point Interview has always been in the
forefront of news propaganda and has received great attention from the Party and
the government. We can say the Focal Point Interview has achieved the
unison of news and propaganda work in both keeping direction and improving the
guidance level, and has become a leading banner for news commentary programs."
Picture: Reporter Li
Yuqiang, who never shows her face and has specialized in slandering Falun Gong.
Main persons in charge of the Focal Point Interview:
Editor and reporter: Li Yuqiang took part in making and reporting many Falun
Gong-slandering programs, both printed and televised. Among them are the series
of programs on "Tiananmen Self-immolation," "Interview with Wang Bo," "Zhejiang
Beggar Case," "Interview with Zhao Ming," and others. (WOIPFG will provide
special reports on these.) Almost all the slanderous programs on the Focal
Point Interview were by Li Yuqiang, who also was the interviewing reporter
on the spot in almost all these cases (attachment 1). When WOIPFG inquired of
other members of the Focal Point Interview group, they clearly pointed
out that Li Yuqiang was the one in charge of Falun Gong programs. Li Yuqiang
made slanderous films, such as "The Nature of Evil Cult is Destroying Lives,"
which is related to the "Tiananmen self-immolation" incident. Li Yuqiang never
showed her face on TV during all the interviews. One could only see his dark
silhouette, mostly from the back.
Photography: Zhang Xuefeng, Lin Gang
Hosts of the Focus Point Interview:
Zhai Shujie, Bo Yang, Jing Yidan, Fang Hongjin
Producer: Liang Jianzeng, Bo Yang,
Sun Kewen, Guan Haiying, Chen Hong
Editor-in-chief: Yang Jihong, Sun Jie
Editor: Li Changsheng, Wang Qibing
Program Inspector-General: Sun
Yusheng
Synthesis: Yang Taozhou
Xinhua News Agency
Director: Tian Congming
Deputy Director: Ma Shengrong
Editor-in-Chief: Nan Zhenzhong
According to incomplete statistics, from January 2000 to October 2003, Xinhua
Net has published 522 articles that slandered Falun Gong.
Reporters Who Have Participated in Slandering Falun Gong
Xu Jiajun (Jilin Branch): Wrote an
article on July 28, 1999 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Zhang Min, Zhou Wei (Beijing Branch):
Wrote an article on February 6, 2001 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Duan Xianju, Ming Xing (Beijing
Branch): Wrote articles on February 17, 18 and 19, 2001 that slandered and
defamed Falun Gong
Zhai Wei, Wang Leiming
(Headquarters): Wrote an article on March 18, 2001 that slandered and defamed
Falun Gong
Gao Jianxin (Headquarters): Wrote an
article on March 20, 2001 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Chen Maodi, Li Zhenghong (Shanghai
Branch): Wrote an article on March 20, 2001 that slandered and defamed Falun
Gong
Li Shanyuan, Yu Li, and Zhang Feifei
(Liaoning Branch): Wrote an article on March 23, 2001 that slandered and defamed
Falun Gong
Li Zhaodong (Headquarters): Wrote an
article on March 28, 2001 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Peng Hong (Headquarters), Wang
Hengtao, Li Lijing (Henan Branch): Wrote an article on March 29, 2001 that
slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Zhang Feifei (Liaoning Branch): Wrote
an article on June 15, 2001 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Wang Leiming, Chen Kaixing, and Ling
Weijia (Headquarters): Wrote an article on June 17, 2001 that slandered and
defamed Falun Gong
Cui Junqiang, Zhang Duo, and Niu
Aimin (Beijing Branch): Wrote an article on December 23, 2001 that slandered and
defamed Falun Gong
Wu Huanqing (Headquarters): Wrote an
article on January 23, 2002 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Wang Hengtao (Henan Branch) and Zhai
Wei (Headquarters): Wrote articles on January 23, 2002 and May 19, 2002 that
slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Jiang Yaping, Lu Dasheng
(Headquarters): Wrote articles on April 17, 18 and 25, 2002 that slandered and
defamed Falun Gong
Shen Hongbing, Hu Jinwu (Jiangxi
Branch): Wrote an article on May 23, 2002 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Wang Leiming (Headquarters), Dong
Zhiyong, Wang Jinliang (Hebei Branch): Wrote an article on June 26, 2002 that
slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Wang Shihuan, Zhao Zhuoyun (Xian
Branch): Wrote an article on August 25, 2002 that slandered and defamed Falun
Gong
Li Shufeng (Headquarters), Qian
Yonghong (Inner Mongolia Branch), and Huang Yan: Wrote an article on May 8, 2002
that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Li Yabiao, Zha Xin (Jilin Branch):
Wrote an article on September 20, 2002 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Niu Jiwei: Wrote articles on July 19,
2001 and July 21, 2002 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Zhang Qizhi, Zhang Heping (Zhejiang
Branch): Wrote an article on July 14, 2003 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Wang Yu (Headquarters): Wrote an
article on August 27, 2003 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
China News Service
Pan Xulin and Qi Bin: Wrote an article on April 8, 2002 that slandered and
defamed Falun Gong
People's Daily
Yuan Jianda: Wrote an article on February 12, 2001 that slandered and defamed
Falun Gong
Guangming Daily
Zhu Weiguang and Wang Qi: Wrote an
article on May 18, 2001 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Gao Jianjin: Wrote an article on
April 17, 2001 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Sun Xiantao: Wrote articles on March
23 and 26, 2001 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Mu Zi: Wrote an article on March 23,
2001 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Liu Liqiang and Wang Shaoxiong: Wrote
an article on Feb. 17, 2001 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Cui Zhijian and Liu Xianqin: Wrote an
article on February 5, 2001 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Xiao Yuhua: Wrote articles on July
29, 1999 and December 8, 1999 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Miao Jiasheng: Wrote articles on
November 27, 1999 and January 3, 2000 that slandered and defamed Falun Gong
Beijing Evening
Yang Hao: Wrote an article on February 16, 2001 that slandered and defamed
Falun Gong
China Youth Daily
Wang Haizhou: Wrote an article on May 20, 2002 that slandered and defamed
Falun Gong
PLA Daily
Yue Shuangxi and Zhang Jianjun: Wrote an article on January 26, 2001 that
slandered and defamed Falun Gong
WOIPFG investigated the people involved in making these false propaganda
programs. When asked why they ignored professional ethics and made up lies, some
of these reporters said, "All articles related to Falun Gong were assigned to
us. I would never have written [them] myself. As a reporter, the boss at the
news agency tells us what to write and what not to write. If he asks me to do an
interview, of course I would do it. If he says I can't write something, then I
can't write it." Another reporter said, "On this issue, I'm not a natural
person, I'm a social person. Please understand. The name I put on the articles
for Xinhua News Agency is reporter xxx, not [speaker's own name], so it's
different." Thus these reporters for the state-run media betray professional
ethics, their sense of justice, and their very consciences. They are in fact
helping a tyrant persecute innocent people.
WOIPFG will send the criminal evidence of related work units and individuals
who slandered and persecuted Falun Gong to international human rights
organizations and file lawsuits against them for their violations of human
rights. Regarding the main work units and the individuals mainly responsible for
using the media to slander and frame Falun Gong, WOIPFG will document and
investigate their cases individually, and will also verify their crimes and
deliver the facts and evidence to the international courts, the human rights
organizations and foreign governments, to sue them and to expose their crimes in
the persecution of Falun Gong.
During the investigation of this case, WOIPFG received help from various
sectors, including some persons in charge of the media, and WOIPFG will
ask the court to take into consideration the assistance they gave in the
investigation. We will not publish the names of individuals and work units who
cooperated with or have assisted WOIPFG in its investigation to determine
the source of slanders. We will keep in mind their positive actions to rectify
their criminal involvement. For those who have missed the opportunity to clarify
matters during the investigation, we hope they can contact us as soon as
possible to provide us with the facts.
Note:
Please contact WOIPFG for the reference list.
